
Once upon a time, which in this case means sometime around the early 1950s, there was this redheaded country boy whose daddy told him to take Molly the mule and plow a field about half a mile down Hamlin Road.
Daddy probably thought that was a complete set of instructions. He knew the farm, knew Molly, knew the walking plow, knew the field and knew all those other little pieces of knowledge a man collects after years of farming until he no longer remembers they are knowledge at all. Red knew some of them. He knew which field Daddy meant, knew Molly well enough, and knew that when Daddy said a field needed plowing, Daddy expected dirt turned over rather than a discussion of agricultural alternatives.
So Red went to get Molly and the plow.
This was Rancho Eno, the family’s farm outside Durham, North Carolina, which Mother had given a Spanish name for reasons that apparently seemed satisfactory at the time. They raised tobacco and other crops, kept livestock, had a tractor, and still had Molly for work that could be accomplished by putting a mule in front of something and a boy behind it. Farm children worked. Nobody called Red into the parlor and asked whether agricultural labor was consistent with his long-term personal goals. Daddy had a field that needed plowing, and Red was available.
There Was One Little Problem
A walking-bottom plow is exactly what its name suggests, except the name doesn’t tell you which member of the arrangement does the walking. The mule walks in front and pulls. The boy walks behind and works. Red had two wooden handles in his hands and a blade below him that had to be driven down into the earth and kept there while Molly leaned into the traces and pulled the whole contraption forward.
Once that blade got down into the Carolina clay and dirt, it did more than scratch a line across the top. It got underneath the earth, lifted it and rolled it over. Heavy clods came up from ground that had been lying flat and packed, breaking apart as they tumbled or landing rough-side-up beside the furrow. Behind Molly and Red, a long continuous row of freshly turned dirt appeared where solid ground had been a few moments before.
Then they had to turn around and do another one.
And another.
There was, however, a small difficulty with beginning any of this. Red needed a plowline running from Molly’s harness back to him looping around the back of his neck and back to the other side of her bridle so he could reach up and grab a line to guide her while simultaneously wrestling that plow through the ground. He looked where the lines ought to have been and they weren’t there. He searched around the barn and anywhere else that seemed reasonable, but the result remained the same: one mule, one plow, one boy, one field and no damned plowline.
Daddy, as fathers in many stories like this are inclined to do immediately after assigning an impossible task, was nowhere useful. Nothing mysterious had happened to him. He was presumably somewhere doing whatever Daddy had to do that day. But he wasn’t standing beside Red saying, “Oh, and son, if you can’t find the plowline, here’s what you do.”
Red had been given a job. Something necessary to do the job was missing. So Red did what boys, and all the future Old Gits of the world have been doing since considerably before anybody started writing operating manuals.
He went looking for something that would work.
And There It Was
The field lay beyond the house along Hamlin Road, so Red looked in the garage as he went by, and there, lo and behold, was a brand-new plowline. Not some rotten old piece of rope hiding behind a bucket. Not a questionable substitute requiring imagination. A new plowline. Providence had provided exactly what Red needed and, as Providence occasionally does when preparing a child for disaster, had provided considerably more of it than necessary.
Red needed enough line to run from Molly back to the plow, around the back of him, and then back to Molly again. About twenty feet. What he had was a whole lot more than that. He did not know how many feet were there, why there were that many feet, or whether the extra length possessed some sacred importance understood by farmers, mule skinners and the Almighty. He knew Daddy had told him to plow the field, he couldn’t plow it without lines, and here was line enough to solve the problem.
So Red cut off what he needed.
There is a lovely simplicity to the reasoning of a boy who has not yet discovered the existence of the rule he is about to violate.
He rigged Molly, hitched her to the walking plow and headed down Hamlin Road. The older rented house was down that way, along with an empty tenant shack and the field beside the woods. By the time Red reached it, whatever problem he had faced back at the barn had been solved. The plowline was in his hands. Molly was in front of him. The plow was behind her. All that remained was the small matter of turning a field.
Molly Pulled and Red Plowed
Now a boy can be told to plow a field in four words, but the field does not give itself up in four words.
Molly leaned into the traces, the harness tightened, and Red pushed the handles down until the plow bit into the ground. The point dug beneath the surface and began lifting the clay and dirt. The plow pulled against his hands, wanting to follow every hard place and every uneven piece of ground, and Red had to hold it down and guide it while Molly supplied the muscle out front.
The earth rolled over beside him in clods. Some broke apart as they fell; others landed whole and rough, leaving a raised brown row stretching behind the boy and mule. The smell of newly opened earth would have been around them, along with the ordinary racket of a Southern farm day—the insects working away in the weeds, birds somewhere around the woods, leather and harness moving as Molly walked, and the scrape and drag of steel working through dirt.
Red walked behind it all.
The sun had the entire field to work on, and it is safe to let a Southern farm day be warm enough to make a boy sweat. His hands had those plow handles to contend with while his feet followed the broken ground. When the blade caught hard clay or something underneath, the handles could push and twist against him. Red had to keep the plow down where it belonged, keep Molly headed where she belonged and keep the new furrow running alongside the last one.
At the end of a row, the whole arrangement had to be turned and lined up again. Then Molly leaned forward, Red put the plow back into the earth, and another strip of the field rolled over. Furrow beside furrow, the unbroken ground slowly disappeared. The woods stayed where they were. The empty tenant shack stayed where it was. Red and Molly went back and forth, back and forth, turning a field one narrow strip at a time.
The Old Git cannot tell you how long it took. Memory has played one of its usual tricks and preserved a picture of the work while throwing away most of the hours required to do it. But Red finished. That much is certain. When he and Molly started, Daddy had an unplowed field. When they were done, the surface had been opened and rolled over into long rows of clay and dirt.
Red had done what Daddy told him to do.
He may even have been proud of himself.
This was because Red did not yet know there had been a second assignment.
Daddy Came Home With the Missing Instructions
At some point Daddy discovered what Red had done to his brand-new plowline, and the boy received a piece of agricultural information that would have been considerably more useful back in the garage before he cut anything.
That line had been forty feet long.
Apparently it was supposed to stay forty feet long.
Daddy knew this. Red didn’t.
Daddy had grown up farming and knew considerably more about mules, plows and plowlines than his eleven- or twelve-year-old son did. There may have been an excellent and perfectly obvious reason that a forty-foot line needed all forty of its feet. To Daddy, cutting it may have been approximately equivalent to sawing the handle off a shovel because the handle looked longer than necessary.
More than seventy years later, the Old Git still doesn’t know what the reason was.
What Red learned that day was that cutting the new line had been wrong. Daddy was furious, and he punished the boy by whipping him with the remaining piece of it. Whippings themselves were not particularly unusual in Red’s childhood. Switches, and sometimes a belt, were part of the disciplinary equipment of the period, and most of those punishments have long since blurred together.
This one stayed.
It stayed not simply because Red got whipped, but because the boy could not understand how he had been expected to know beforehand what he learned only afterward. Nobody had told him not to cut the new line. Nobody had explained that its full length mattered. Daddy had told him to plow a field. Red had encountered a problem preventing him from plowing it, found a way around the problem, and then spent however many hours it took walking behind Molly and turning Daddy’s clay over one furrow at a time.
The field was plowed.
Then Red discovered there had been another rule.
The Old Git Found Another Question Seventy Years Later
There is a second mystery hiding in that field, although Red didn’t notice it at the time. The Old Git doesn’t remember Daddy ever sending him out to plow another entire field behind Molly. That proves almost nothing, because childhood loses enormous chunks of itself on the trip to eighty-four, but this is the one complete mule-plowed field that comes readily back.
The family also owned a tractor. Daddy had a gang plow for it, and a tractor pulling several plow bottoms could turn a great deal more earth on each trip across a field than Molly pulling one while a redheaded boy trudged along behind. The difference would not have required an advanced course in agricultural economics. Red could have measured it in footsteps.
So the Old Git now wonders why Daddy sent him down Hamlin Road with Molly in the first place. Maybe there was a practical reason the tractor couldn’t be used. Maybe Daddy thought a farm boy ought to know how to plow behind a mule. Maybe it was a test. Maybe Daddy simply had a field, a mule and a boy and saw no reason all three shouldn’t be occupied.
Any of those would fit nicely.
Which is why the storyteller isn’t going to tell you which one happened.
Nobody knows.
Red certainly wasn’t wondering about it while he was in the field. He had Molly’s lines in his hands, the plow fighting the earth below him and another stretch of unturned ground ahead. The questions had to sit there for most of a lifetime until Red became the Old Git and started poking around in things that had once seemed too ordinary to deserve examination.
Daddy and Red Were Looking at Different Rope
That’s when something else becomes visible in the story. Daddy and Red could have stood side by side in that garage looking at exactly the same forty feet of new plowline and seen two entirely different objects.
Daddy saw a piece of farm equipment. He knew what it was for, how it was supposed to be used, why it was made that length and, presumably, what would be ruined if some damned kid came along and cut a chunk out of it.
Red saw the missing piece of Daddy’s instructions.
There was nothing mysterious about the difference. Daddy possessed information Red didn’t possess. The interesting part is how easily information disappears from the view of the person who already has it. Daddy knew why the line mattered so thoroughly that it may never have occurred to him that his son didn’t know. Once something becomes obvious inside one person’s head, it has a peculiar tendency to become something everybody ought to know.
“Go plow the field” sounded like a complete instruction because Daddy already carried everything else those words required. Red didn’t. He discovered the first missing piece when he couldn’t find a plowline. He discovered the second missing piece when Daddy came home angry.
Red Solved the Problem He Could See
For most of his life, the Old Git could have told this as a simple story about a boy solving one problem and accidentally creating another. But looking backward now, that isn’t quite what happened. There were two problems in the story from the beginning. Red could see only one of them.
The visible problem was: How does a boy plow this field when he can’t find a plowline? Red solved that one. He found line, rigged Molly, went down Hamlin Road, put the plow deep into the clay and walked until the field behind him was rows of turned earth.
The invisible problem was: How does the boy accomplish all of that without damaging something whose importance he has never been told?
There was no clever solution available for that one. A person cannot take account of information he does not possess.
Perhaps Red should have waited for Daddy. Perhaps he should have searched longer. Perhaps an eleven- or twelve-year-old farm boy should have known better than to cut a brand-new piece of equipment without permission. Perhaps Daddy should have told him where the proper line was. There is room in the story for all of those possibilities, and there is no need to haul Daddy before some imaginary court seventy years later and decide who was guilty.
The interesting part isn’t deciding who was right. It is noticing that two people can be standing inside the same situation while one of them possesses the fact that makes the correct decision obvious and the other doesn’t even know the fact exists.
Everybody Knows That
It still happens. A manager knows why a procedure exists while the new employee sees an unnecessary extra step. A parent knows why something is dangerous while the child sees something interesting to climb. A fellow who has done a job for twenty years watches somebody who has been doing it for twenty minutes and says, “Everybody knows you don’t do that.”
Well, everybody who already knows may know.
Sometimes the rule is important. Sometimes the rule is obsolete. Sometimes the newcomer who doesn’t know the rule discovers a better way precisely because nobody has yet taught him all the reasons something supposedly cannot be done. But until the knowledge behind a rule gets from one head into another, the poor devil trying to solve the immediate problem may be standing in a garage looking at forty feet of perfectly useful plowline and wondering why in hell he shouldn’t cut off what he needs.
How Was the Old Git Supposed to Know?
There is probably a forty-foot plowline somewhere in almost everybody’s history. Maybe you were the one who got in trouble for violating a rule nobody had bothered to tell you. You were criticized at work, marked down at school, punished at home or informed that you had demonstrated poor judgment when, from everything you knew at the time, your judgment made perfectly good sense.
Or perhaps you’ve been Daddy. You gave somebody instructions that seemed perfectly clear, watched in horror as they did something you couldn’t imagine anybody doing, and heard yourself say, “You should have known better.” Sometimes that’s exactly right. But there is another question worth asking before the matter is closed: How were they supposed to know?
If you’ve got a forty-foot-plowline story of your own, bring it over to Your Ideas and tell the Old Git about it. Tell him what happened, what you actually knew at the time, and what somebody else apparently knew that you didn’t. Or tell him about the day you were Daddy and discovered that an instruction you thought was complete had a hole in it large enough to drive a tractor through.
Red went down Hamlin Road with Molly, a walking plow and a piece cut from a brand-new forty-foot line. He spent the day with the handles pushing against his hands, the plow down in the Carolina clay and Molly pulling ahead while solid ground rolled over into clods behind them. Furrow by furrow, he turned Daddy’s field exactly as he had been told.
Then he came home and discovered the part Daddy hadn’t told him.
More than seventy years later, the Old Git still doesn’t know why that plowline needed to be forty feet long. He remembers the mule. He remembers the plow. He remembers that field beside the woods, and he remembers learning that he had done something wrong only after he had finished doing what Daddy sent him there to do.
Which leaves one small question still walking along behind Molly after all these years: How in the hell was Red supposed to know?
