
Not knowing something gives the Old Git an itch in a place a gentleman is not supposed to scratch in public.
He has been afflicted with this condition for eighty-four years. Show him something that doesn’t make sense and he will take it apart, turn it over, ask somebody an impertinent question, look underneath it, and eventually develop an explanation possessing considerably more confidence than evidence. Instructions may become involved, but ordinarily only after several more promising methods have failed.
There is nothing particularly unusual about the Old Git in this regard. Most of the congregation suffers from the same disease. Something happens, we don’t know why it happened, and that empty little spot where the answer ought to be starts itching. Pretty soon somebody says, “Well, I’ll tell you what happened,” and away we go, constructing bridges over territory nobody has actually surveyed.
Sometimes the bridge is useful. A possible explanation gives us somewhere to look next. Trouble begins when everybody forgets which end of the bridge was sitting on solid ground and which end we built out over the swamp because an empty space made us nervous.
Consider the Shower, Dear Hearts
The Old Git says he often gets an idea while taking a shower. This is probably not because showers are unusually intellectual places. A man standing naked with soap in his eyes is not generally regarded as civilization’s highest form of reasoning apparatus. Nevertheless, there he is shampooing what remains of his hair when an idea that has apparently been hiding for three days walks in and reports for duty.
Now comes the interesting part. The Old Git knows the idea occurred. He may remember the exact moment it occurred. He may even remember which part of what remains of his hair he was washing when it happened. What he does not necessarily know is where the damned idea came from.
Give him five minutes, however, and he can probably tell you.
He was thinking about the problem yesterday. Something he read last week may have contributed. A conversation at breakfast stirred an old memory. Perhaps his mind had continued working while he was doing something else. Every one of those possibilities sounds perfectly respectable, and one of them might even be right.
The small fly floating around in that intellectual ointment is that the Old Git may not possess one scrap of evidence showing which one actually happened. A plausible explanation has an unfortunate tendency, after being repeated a few times, to put on a necktie and introduce itself as the explanation.
Eighty-Four Years Leaves a Lot of Holes
This became troublesome when the Old Git started going backward through his life trying to discover where some of his ideas came from. He has accumulated a fairly ridiculous inventory to search: farm kid, soldier, radio and television fellow, restaurant operator, commercial lender, businessman, inventor, salesman and assorted other occupations undertaken before anybody could stop him.
Along the way he encountered machines, people, systems, mistakes and problems that disappeared from daily use decades ago. Now he can sometimes look at something he created later and see an earlier experience that resembles part of it. That is when temptation comes strolling down the aisle wearing perfume.
Suppose Red encountered something in 1965, and thirty years later the Old Git can see something remarkably similar inside an idea Red had in 1995. Well now, dear hearts, wouldn’t it be pleasant to draw a nice straight line between those two things? There is the source. Mystery solved. Put a little brass plaque on it and everybody can go home.
Except the evidence doesn’t necessarily say that.
The earlier encounter establishes that the material was available to Red. It does not establish that thirty years later his mind went rummaging through the attic, found that particular box, blew off the dust and said, “By God, this is exactly what we need.” Unless Red remembered making the connection, wrote it down, told somebody about it, or left some other evidence connecting the two, there is a hole in the story.
The Old Git doesn’t particularly like the hole. That is precisely why he has learned to keep an eye on it.
There Ain’t a Damned Thing Wrong With Guessing
Now somebody in the back pew is preparing an objection. If nobody is allowed to consider anything that can’t already be proved, human inquiry is going to become mighty dull. Quite a bit of progress has begun with somebody looking at an unexplained thing and saying, in language cleaned up for publication, I wonder if this damned thing works like that.
The Old Git agrees completely. Speculation isn’t the problem. Unlabeled speculation is the problem.
There is a world of difference between saying, “This happened because…” and saying, “I wonder whether this happened because….” The first sentence quietly fills the hole and starts pouring concrete. The second puts a little flag beside the hole so everybody can gather around and have a proper look into it.
Once the flag is there, useful questions can begin. If the guess is right, what else ought to be true? Is there another explanation that fits just as well? Has this happened to somebody else? Has anybody studied it? Is there some way to test the proposition without electrocuting a graduate student?
A guess can be a perfectly respectable beginning to an investigation. It just shouldn’t be allowed to sneak across the border wearing knowledge’s overcoat.
The Old Git Has Accomplices Now
As though one elderly fellow manufacturing explanations weren’t enough, the Old Git now works with several artificial intelligences. This may demonstrate either admirable intellectual curiosity or a lifelong inability to leave well enough alone. He gives the machines memories, stories, questions, old records and half-formed notions, and they help compare things, look for relationships, challenge interpretations and occasionally uncover something that causes the Old Git to sit back and say, “Well, I’ll be damned.”
They are also magnificent explanation machines.
Give one of them two events and ask how the events might be related, and the machine may build a bridge between them so beautiful you want to install lighting and charge admission. The bridge may be psychologically plausible, historically plausible, logically arranged and expressed in prose smooth enough to skate on. There remains one small inconvenience: the bridge may never have existed.
Before anybody starts blaming the machine, however, Brother Dave would like the congregation to inspect its own property. Human beings have been doing precisely the same thing since long before electricity. Give a man two events, a missing explanation and sufficient confidence, and by supper he may have a theory, three supporting anecdotes and an uncle who knew somebody who proved it.
Being human does not confer immunity from turning incomplete evidence into a good story. Humans merely have seniority.
Sometimes We Haven’t Got a Clue
That is why the Old Git wants the machinery around this website to keep different things in different buckets. Sometimes there will be good evidence that two things are related. Sometimes there will be a reasonable possibility worth investigating. Sometimes two things will merely look suspiciously alike, and sometimes everybody involved—the Old Git, his artificial accomplices and any innocent bystanders who have wandered into Gitland—will simply not have a clue.
There is nothing disgraceful about that last bucket.
“We don’t know” is not where an investigation necessarily ends. Sometimes it is the first accurate thing anybody has said about the matter. Once the Old Git has reached the place where the evidence stops, leaving the space empty allows everybody to see where the boundary actually is.
Suppose an old memory suddenly returns after sixty years. If the Old Git announces confidently why it returned, everybody else is reduced to believing him or arguing with him. If he says he doesn’t know why it returned but can describe what happened immediately beforehand, now there is something to investigate. What might have triggered it? What else could explain it? Has the same thing happened to other people? Is there research that bears on it?
Now somebody else’s experience matters. Contradictions matter. Research matters. Even the fellow who wanders in and says, “Old man, you’re looking at the wrong damned thing,” has performed a useful public service.
And Now, Dear Hearts, We Come to You
It would be comforting to leave this as the Old Git’s problem, perhaps aggravated by his collection of artificial accomplices, but Brother Dave cannot permit the congregation to escape that easily. You have explanations for things you do not actually know too.
You know why the boss rejected your suggestion. You know why your husband or wife didn’t answer. You know why customers stopped buying something, why your daughter made that decision, why the dog is staring at the refrigerator, and why Uncle Fred hasn’t called since Christmas. Some of those explanations are undoubtedly correct. The interesting question is which ones you know and which ones merely fit.
Nobody is suggesting that Uncle Fred be detained pending peer review. The experiment is considerably smaller. Every once in a while, when you catch yourself explaining something, separate what actually happened from the part you supplied to make what happened make sense.
If there isn’t much evidence left after the sorting, the explanation does not necessarily have to be thrown away. Just change the label. Maybe. One possibility is. I suspect. I wonder whether. Those aren’t cowardly words when uncertainty is real. They’re handles that let you pick up an unexplained thing, turn it over and keep examining it without pretending the examination has already ended.
Welcome to We Haven’t Got a Clue
That is why Gitland has a place called We Haven’t Got a Clue. It isn’t a graveyard where failed questions are taken out behind the shed and quietly disposed of. It is a holding pen for questions whose explanations have outrun their evidence.
Some of those questions may stay there forever. The Old Git is eighty-four, so forever has become a somewhat more manageable research period. Others may eventually bump into a reader who knows something the rest of us don’t. One may collide with research nobody had found. Somebody else’s experience may contradict the whole proposition and send everybody back to the beginning.
That is not failure. If everybody discovers exactly where an explanation goes wrong, they have discovered something. Occasionally the hole in what we know is more useful than the beautiful bridge somebody built across it.
Go Ahead and Scratch It
So here is the invitation. Think of something you’re quite certain you understand, particularly something involving another person’s motives, one of your own memories, or where an idea came from. Then strip away everything inferred and leave only what you can reasonably say actually happened.
If that exercise leaves a hole where your lovely explanation used to be, don’t rush to fill it back in. Poke around the edges. See what is evidence and what is interpretation. See whether there might be another explanation sitting nearby looking equally respectable.
And if you find a particularly interesting hole, bring the damned thing over to Your Ideas and let the Old Git and his accomplices scratch at it with you. Tell them what you know, what you think might explain it, and where the evidence runs out. That’s considerably more useful than polishing the guess until everybody mistakes it for a fact.
Because not knowing really does itch. The trick isn’t learning not to scratch. The trick is remembering, while everybody is scratching away, which parts of the damned thing they actually know.
