
Two Sets of Books
Dear hearts, there are certain discoveries an Asset-Based Lending examiner does not particularly want to make.
An examiner can spend several pleasant days counting somebody else’s inventory, tracing invoices, checking receivables, looking under accounting rocks for financial snakes, and generally behaving like the suspicious son of a gun the lender is paying him to be. Most of the time, the borrower would prefer that he finish his work, eat his supper, catch his airplane and take his suspicious nature someplace else.
But there are certain things that will cause an examiner to quit worrying about supper.
Two sets of books will do it.
Now, this wasn’t a case where the company had a general ledger and another accounting report that happened to contain some of the same information. Red was examining a cut-and-sew operation in Star, North Carolina, and discovered that these folks were maintaining two sets of financial records.
That tends to get an examiner’s attention because companies ordinarily don’t go to the trouble of keeping two versions of financial reality unless somebody has decided that one version of reality is unsuitable for somebody else’s consumption. And when Red represented the outfit lending them money, his immediate concern was that his employer might be the somebody.
So Red started worrying at it.
Red was working for Southeastern Financial Corporation in those days, and their business was lending money against assets such as accounts receivable and inventory. If a borrower said it had a million dollars in receivables, Southeastern did not simply admire the million dollars and compliment everybody on how nicely the commas had been arranged. Somebody had to determine whether customers really owed that money, whether the invoices were legitimate, whether they had already been paid, and whether the fellow who prepared the report had developed any innovative accounting theories that might eventually interest the district attorney.
That somebody, on this particular examination, was Red, and Red had just found two sets of books.
Except Everybody Knew About Them
Well now, friends and neighbors, a proper detective story requires that the detective discover something everybody else doesn’t know.
This wasn’t one of those.
The people at Star Manufacturing knew about the second books. Management knew. Southeastern Financial knew. Apparently everybody who needed to know about these secret books knew about them except the one person anybody might reasonably expect to be entitled to know what was going on inside Star Manufacturing.
The owner.
Now, you have to appreciate the peculiar shape of this thing. Here was a man who owned a company, and the people running his company were deliberately maintaining financial information in such a fashion that the owner could not determine precisely how much borrowing capacity his own company possessed.
And the lender knew they were doing it.
By this point Red’s normal examiner instincts had gotten themselves twisted into something resembling a pretzel at a Baptist picnic. Usually, if Red discovered that the borrower was concealing financial information from somebody, he wanted to know why. If he discovered that his own employer already knew about the concealment, he wanted to know why considerably faster.
The answer involved God, Oral Roberts, a promise made by a dying man, and a group of employees trying desperately to keep their boss from giving away the company they worked for.
That is not a situation an ABL examiner expects to encounter while tracing accounts receivable.
The Promise
As the story was explained to Red at the time, the owner of Star Manufacturing had become gravely ill. He apparently believed he was going to die, and somewhere in that frightening stretch of life he made a bargain with the Almighty.
If God would let him live, he would give everything he had to the Lord.
Now, Red wasn’t about to get into the theology of negotiating with God because he had been sent there to examine collateral, not determine whether the Almighty had accepted the terms and conditions. What mattered to the examination was that the man recovered, and when he recovered, he remembered the promise.
That last part is important. Human beings have made promises while frightened since approximately Thursday afternoon after Creation, and a considerable number of those promises have developed memory problems once the danger passed. This fellow apparently did not suffer from that particular deficiency.
He started giving his money away.
A substantial portion of that giving went to Oral Roberts and the religious work associated with him, including Oral Roberts University in Tulsa. Oral Roberts was already a nationally prominent evangelist, and the owner of Star Manufacturing wasn’t dropping spare change into the collection plate on Sunday morning. He was giving enough money that he eventually became a member of the university’s Board of Trustees.
And there sat the problem, because the man had promised to give away what he had, and Star Manufacturing was one of the things he had.
When Generosity Becomes a Credit Problem
The people running Star Manufacturing had a perspective on this spiritual arrangement that was somewhat more earthly.
They had employees to pay. They had fabric to buy. They had garments to manufacture. They had customers to serve. They had a company to keep alive, and Southeastern Financial had money loaned against the assets of that company.
The owner, meanwhile, had discovered something that can be terribly exciting to a generous man who has promised God everything: borrowing capacity.
If the company had additional assets against which Southeastern Financial was willing to advance more money, then the owner could borrow more money. And if he could borrow more money, he could give more money away, which was perfectly logical if a fellow started with the proposition that the Lord had kept His side of the bargain and it was now time for him to keep his.
There is a certain magnificent simplicity to that reasoning, provided a person is not one of the people responsible for making payroll after the owner finishes being magnificent.
So the employees found themselves in the unusual position of trying to protect the company from the generosity of the man who owned it. Southeastern Financial, having a financial interest in the survival of its borrower, had reason to be interested too.
That was the reason for the financial arrangements Red had stumbled into.
The information being concealed wasn’t designed to persuade the lender that Star Manufacturing had more collateral than it actually possessed. The lender already knew what was happening. The information was being controlled so the owner couldn’t determine how much more money his own company might be able to borrow, because additional borrowing capacity represented additional money he could give away.
They weren’t trying to stop a thief from stealing the company. They were trying to stop its owner from giving it away, which put Red in the unusual position of discovering suspicious accounting and gradually becoming less suspicious the more it was explained to him.
Now, dear hearts, if you’ve ever worked somewhere that had a rule, system, accounting trick, family arrangement, or downright peculiar contraption that made absolutely no sense until somebody told you the story behind it, Red would like to hear about it. Throw it over the fence and tell us what happened. Those are exactly the sorts of stories Old Gits worry at.
A Man Can Give Away Only What He Can Get His Hands On
Eventually the employees gained enough control over the financial side of the business that the owner could no longer give as freely as he had before.
That apparently accomplished what the employees and the lender needed it to accomplish. More of the company’s resources remained available to operate the company rather than being converted into additional donations, and the people who depended upon Star Manufacturing for their paychecks could presumably sleep a little better without wondering how much of next month’s operating capital might shortly develop a religious calling.
But there was another consequence.
With less money under his control, the owner gave less money to Oral Roberts, and after his giving declined, according to what Red learned in connection with the company, the owner was dropped from the Oral Roberts University board.
Now, dear hearts, Red was perfectly willing to leave the theological conclusions to somebody with better credentials and cleaner shoes. He was an Asset-Based Lending examiner. His job was to determine whether the assets existed, whether the collateral supported the loan, and whether Southeastern Financial was likely to get its money back.
But he had been sent into Star Manufacturing because numbers were supposed to tell him something about a business, and what those numbers eventually told him was one of the strangest business stories he encountered in all those years of crawling around inside other people’s companies.
A man got sick and thought he was dying. Somewhere in that experience, he promised God everything if he lived. Then he lived, which presented the fellow with the inconvenient necessity of deciding whether he’d meant what he’d said when he thought he was dying.
Apparently, he had.
So he gave.
He gave enough to get onto a university board, and he kept giving until the people around him became afraid that his generosity might damage the company producing the money he was giving. They gained control of the finances, which meant he couldn’t give as much anymore, and when he couldn’t give as much anymore, he lost the board seat his giving had helped bring him.
Somewhere in there is a lesson about religion, money, generosity, business, human nature, or possibly all five wrestling one another behind the woodshed. Red wasn’t entirely certain which one won.
What he did know was that he had walked into Star Manufacturing, discovered two sets of books, and encountered what may have been the only ABL examination of his career where discovering the secret books made the situation less suspicious after he learned what they were for.
For once, nobody was keeping two sets of books to fool the lender.
They were keeping them to keep a generous man from discovering how much more he could give away.
And friends and neighbors, after years of looking for people who were hiding assets from the bank, Red had finally found a company hiding the bank from its owner.
Red has accumulated a fair-sized collection of stories like this, but he surely didn’t corner the market. Somewhere in your life is probably a story that sounds impossible until you explain why it happened. Send it to The Old Gits Website. Give us the pieces, even if you don’t think it’s a story yet. Sometimes the peculiar little piece is where the story starts.
Got an idea, question, correction, or connection? Tell The Old Git.
