
Some inventions become embarrassingly obvious about fifteen minutes after somebody else invents them.
You look at the finished thing and think, Well, hell, of course. Put wheels on luggage. Put a camera in a telephone. Put a handle on something that is inconvenient to carry. Once the pieces are together, they can look as though they had been sitting around for years wondering what took us so damned long.
Which, in many cases, they had.
That interests me because the pieces of a new idea don’t necessarily have to be new. Sometimes the new thing is simply a relationship that didn’t exist—or at least hadn’t been noticed—between things that were already lying around.
Take two things that have been around for years. They may do completely different jobs. They may come from different businesses, different sciences, different generations, or different drawers in the garage. Then somebody looks at one, remembers something about the other, and asks a wonderfully unsophisticated question: Reckon those two things can fit together?
I like that question because it doesn’t require us to know where we’re going before we start.
You Don’t Have to Invent the Pieces
We tend to give inventors more magical powers than they probably deserve. We see the finished result and imagine somebody sitting alone in a room creating the whole damned thing from nothing. Certainly people sometimes create genuinely new components, but a great many useful ideas also seem to come from putting existing things into relationships they hadn’t occupied before.
Consider the wheeled suitcase. Human beings had been making containers for carrying things for a very long time, and we had become reasonably proficient at making wheels. Neither required a sudden flash of genius before somebody could notice that dragging or carrying a heavy suitcase was a damned nuisance and wonder whether those two old acquaintances ought to be introduced.
Now that we’re accustomed to luggage with wheels, luggage without them looks slightly ridiculous. That’s hindsight playing one of its little tricks. The combination seems inevitable after we’ve seen it.
The same kind of borrowing can happen where the connection is less visible. A restaurant owner sees something a factory does and realizes part of the process might work in a kitchen. A teacher borrows something from a game. A nurse changes a procedure after noticing how somebody organizes tools. A software designer recognizes something useful in a system that has absolutely nothing to do with computers.
In each case, the interesting part may not be creation of a new piece. The pieces were already there. What hadn’t existed before was that particular arrangement of them.
Things Come Apart in Your Head
This is where I have become interested in something I call patterns and elements. Don’t run away. You don’t have to study my model before you’re allowed to have an idea, and I am certainly not suggesting that your brain contains little boxes conveniently labeled PATTERN and ELEMENT.
I use element as a working name for a piece of something we’ve encountered. A wheel can be an element. So can a handle, sound, procedure, shape, rule, phrase, way of fastening two things together, or the peculiar way somebody solved a problem forty years ago. What interests me is the possibility that those pieces don’t have to remain permanently attached to the things where we first encountered them.
Suppose you once worked in a restaurant and learned a particular way of organizing customers when things got busy. Years later you’re sitting in a doctor’s office where everybody is confused about who is next, and something about that mess reminds you of the restaurant. You haven’t transported the restaurant into the doctor’s office. You didn’t bring the grill, waiters, menus or the fellow at table twelve who has been complaining about his soup for twenty minutes. Something smaller traveled.
I use pattern for the larger recognizable arrangement in which those pieces participate. You recognize a bicycle because its various parts are related in a way you’ve learned to recognize as a bicycle. You recognize a restaurant, baseball game, sales meeting or birthday party in much the same way.
Here’s the part that keeps bothering me: an element doesn’t necessarily belong to only one pattern. A wheel can participate in a bicycle, shopping cart, automobile, office chair, wheelbarrow, hospital bed or suitcase. The wheel hasn’t changed its allegiance. It simply happens to be useful in several different arrangements.
Once I started looking at ideas that way, I began noticing pieces everywhere.
Now Screw With It
Find something near you that you understand reasonably well and, instead of looking at the finished thing, take it apart in your head. Ask what its pieces are, what each piece does, and which pieces you normally ignore because you’ve become accustomed to seeing the whole thing.
Then pick one piece and ask where else you’ve encountered something that performs a similar job. It doesn’t have to look the same. In fact, the more interesting connection may be between things that appear to have no business knowing one another.
A restaurant waiting list and a computer queue don’t look alike. A factory assembly line and the way people move through an airport don’t look alike. A beehive and a business organization certainly don’t look alike. Yet some relationship inside one may resemble, solve, alter or illuminate something inside another.
This is where I would resist the temptation to become sensible too quickly. We have plenty of time later to determine that an idea is impractical, expensive, impossible, illegal or simply stupid. At this stage we’re only allowing one familiar piece to wander away from home and asking whether it recognizes anything.
Reckon those two things can fit together? Maybe they can’t. Maybe they fit beautifully and produce something utterly useless. But every once in a while we may see an arrangement that wasn’t visible before, and that’s when things get interesting.
I Wonder Whether You Do This Too
I’ve been looking backward through my own life trying to understand how some of my ideas developed, and I keep finding pieces that seem to have traveled. Something encountered in one business turns up years later in another. Something learned from a machine becomes useful when thinking about people. An old experience that seemed to have nothing to do with a current problem suddenly becomes relevant because one part of it fits.
Those observations helped lead me toward the model I’m developing about patterns, elements, encounters and the relationships among them. You’ll find more about that under The Model on this website if you’re curious. But I am considerably more interested in discovering whether other people’s experiences support it, contradict it, or send us somewhere I haven’t thought to look.
Studying my own ideas presents a rather obvious problem: they’re mine. I know a fair amount about what has happened inside one life because I’ve been stuck in the damned thing for eighty-four years. What I don’t know is whether the same sort of traveling pieces will become visible when you go backward through an idea of your own.
So before we go any farther, try one. Think of some little solution, improvement or contraption of your own and ask where its pieces came from. If you discover that you borrowed something from a place where it seemingly had no business being useful, bring that wandering piece over to Your Ideas and tell us where it started and where it wound up. I’m particularly interested in connections between things that appear unrelated.
Have You Ever Caught Yourself Doing It?
The idea doesn’t need to have made you rich, earned a patent or changed civilization. Maybe you changed something at work, rearranged your kitchen, found an easier way to perform an annoying chore, made something in your garage, or solved a problem everybody else had simply learned to tolerate.
Now go backward through it and see whether you can recognize where some of its pieces came from. Was there something in your solution that you had encountered somewhere else? Did you deliberately borrow it, or did the relationship simply occur to you? Perhaps you only recognized the connection afterward. Perhaps you’ve never thought about where the pieces came from at all. That last possibility may be the most interesting one.
The Your Ideas section is where we can collect those things. You don’t have to prove anything, and you certainly don’t have to learn my terminology before you’re allowed through the door. Tell us what you made, changed, noticed or wondered about. Tell us about the apparently unrelated things that somehow came together. If you don’t know where one of the pieces came from, tell us that too.
Then we can worry at it together. Another visitor may recognize something from a completely different experience. I may see a relationship to something in mine. One of the artificial-intelligence systems I work with may turn up history or research that gives us somewhere else to look. Sometimes we’ll probably discover that our wonderful new idea was patented during the administration of Millard Fillmore. That’s fine too. The object isn’t to prove we’re geniuses. The object is to learn more about what happens when things meet.
So have a look at something familiar. Break it into pieces in your head, pick up one of those pieces, and mentally carry it somewhere it has no obvious business going. Then look around and ask the wonderfully unsophisticated question: Reckon those two things can fit together?
If the answer surprises you, bring the combination back and show us what happened. It doesn’t have to work. Something that almost fits, fails spectacularly, or sends us off in an entirely different direction may give us just as much to think about.
