
There is a small world operating inside your toilet that you may have lived three feet away from for years without ever meeting.
As long as everything works, this causes no difficulty. You push the handle, various watery events occur, the evidence disappears, and civilization continues. You don’t need to know who did what to whom inside the tank. You and the toilet have an agreement: you push the handle and it handles the details.
Then one morning you push the handle and nothing happens.
Now you’re interested.
You take the lid off the tank and discover water, a float, a valve, a chain, a rubber contraption at the bottom and perhaps several other objects that have apparently been conducting business back there without supervision. Move the handle and one thing lifts another. Something opens. Water moves. The float changes position. Another valve does something. Eventually, if all goes according to plan, the whole contraption returns to where it started and waits patiently for you to bother it again.
That’s the moment I enjoy. The mysterious whole has come apart into pieces, and even before I understand all of them, I can begin to see relationships. This moves because that moved. This can’t happen until that happens first. And somewhere about then the question that got me into the tank in the first place becomes considerably more interesting: How does this damn thing work?
Knowing What It Is Isn’t Knowing How It Works
I have been taking things apart for as long as I can remember. That statement may cause some alarm among people who own things I happen to be standing near, so perhaps I should qualify it. I don’t necessarily mean taking them apart with a screwdriver. I have certainly done my share of that, sometimes even managing to put everything back together without several mysterious pieces left on the table. What I mean is that when I encounter something I don’t understand, sooner or later I want to know what is going on inside it.
We live surrounded by things we know perfectly well without understanding them in the slightest. I am writing this on a computer. I know what a computer is, and I can operate one reasonably well, although the computer and I occasionally have differing opinions about which of us is doing the operating. I know that when I press a key, a letter appears on the screen. I also know there is a long and complicated explanation of what happens between my finger moving and that letter appearing, most of which would cause my eyes to glaze over somewhere around the third semiconductor.
That doesn’t prevent me from using the thing. Most of life works that way. You turn a faucet and water comes out. You press the brake pedal and several thousand pounds of automobile rather obligingly stop moving. You swallow an aspirin and, with any luck, your headache improves. We learn the relationship between what we do and what happens next, and ordinarily that is enough.
It stops being enough when the faucet starts making a noise, the brake pedal feels funny, the aspirin doesn’t help, or the computer displays a message apparently written by somebody who considers English an unnecessary extravagance. The familiar thing becomes unfamiliar for a moment, and curiosity gets another chance at it.
Most Things Are Made of Other Things
That sounds embarrassingly obvious until you begin paying attention to it. A bicycle is made of parts. So is a restaurant. So is a football game, a business, a family reunion, a traffic jam and the federal government, although in that last case identifying what some of the parts are supposed to accomplish may require additional research.
The physical things are easiest to see. A bicycle has wheels, pedals, a chain, handlebars, bearings, brakes and a seat designed by somebody whose opinion of the human backside may deserve examination. But merely listing the pieces doesn’t explain the bicycle. The interesting part is what the pieces do to one another. Push the pedal and the crank turns. The crank moves the chain. The chain turns the rear wheel. The wheel pushes against the ground, and off you go until something else in the arrangement—or an oak tree—persuades you to stop.
Once you see those pieces and relationships, bicycle becomes more than the name of the whole object. You have begun to see what is happening inside the name.
The same trick works on things that aren’t machines. Take a restaurant. Somebody orders food. That information has to reach somebody who prepares it. The ingredients have to be available before the order arrives. The finished food has to find its way back to the correct customer. Money has to move in the opposite direction. Dirty dishes have to become clean dishes, tables occupied by one group eventually have to become available to another, and somewhere in the middle of all this somebody has to notice that table twelve still hasn’t received its soup.
I don’t mean that people are machine parts. I mean that the activity contains pieces and relationships. Change one of those relationships and something somewhere else may change with it. Slow the kitchen and tables remain occupied longer. Change the way orders reach the kitchen and mistakes may increase or decrease. Speed up one part without changing another and you may simply move the waiting somewhere else.
Now my curiosity has considerably more to work with.
What Happens If I Poke This Bit?
Once you begin seeing pieces, you can start wondering about their relationships. What causes what? What depends on what? Which piece is necessary, and which one is there merely because somebody has always done it that way? What happens if one piece disappears? What happens if it gets bigger, smaller, faster, slower, cheaper, stronger or moves somewhere else?
This is also where perfectly respectable examination can deteriorate into fooling around, which I recommend from time to time. A child does this naturally. Give a child something unfamiliar and, provided no adult has yet said, “Don’t touch that,” the child turns it over, shakes it, pokes it, opens whatever will open, and attempts to determine whether any portion of it will fit into another portion where the designer clearly had no intention of putting it.
The child may not know the word for it, but there is an investigation going on. Somewhere along the road to becoming responsible adults, many of us learn to stop doing that. We learn what the thing is called, what it is for, and the approved way of using it. That is undoubtedly helpful for maintaining an orderly society, but I wonder whether we surrender something useful when knowing the approved answer causes us to stop asking about all the other bits.
I never entirely got over that habit, which may explain a fair portion of both the successes and the wreckage scattered through my life.
Then Comes the Dangerous Question
Once you understand a little about how something works, another question tends to sneak in: Why does it have to work that way? That one can be troublesome because sometimes there is an excellent answer. The thing works that way because somebody spent thirty years discovering all the other ways that don’t work. There may be laws of physics involved, safety requirements, costs, materials, human anatomy, or some other stubborn piece of reality that has no interest whatsoever in our wonderful new idea.
But occasionally the answer is less impressive: We’ve always done it that way. That’s when my ears perk up.
The old way isn’t automatically wrong. Things frequently become customary because they work rather well. But once the explanation for a particular piece or relationship becomes merely “that’s how it’s done,” I want to know who decided it, what problem they were solving, whether that problem still exists, and what would happen if somebody moved the furniture around.
That’s one of the places an ordinary question can become an idea. You don’t begin by demanding an invention. You begin by understanding enough of the existing arrangement to notice that one of its relationships might not be inevitable.
If you’ve ever looked at something in your own work or life and thought, I understand what this does, but why in hell do we do it THIS way?, bring that troublesome little question over to Your Ideas. Tell us what the thing does, how it presently works, and which part or relationship refuses to make sense to you. You don’t need the solution. The question is enough.
Your World Contains Things Mine Doesn’t
This is where you become considerably more interesting to me than my toilet. You know how things work that I have never encountered. Maybe you spent your life repairing aircraft, teaching third grade, laying concrete, raising children, running a warehouse, selling insurance, programming computers, nursing patients, growing tomatoes, driving trucks, or doing something I don’t even know exists.
That means you have seen pieces and relationships I haven’t. More importantly, you have probably encountered things in your own world that you don’t completely understand either. Perhaps you’ve wondered about them for years. Perhaps everybody around you accepts something as normal and you’re the irritating person who keeps asking why. Perhaps you’ve figured out how something works but still can’t understand why anybody designed it that way in the first place.
That’s part of what Your Ideas is for on this website. You don’t need to have solved the problem, and you don’t even need to be certain there is a problem. Tell us what you’re looking at, what it does, and what about it makes you wonder. Somebody else may know the answer. Your question may remind another person of something apparently unrelated. It may bump into one of my experiences. One of the artificial-intelligence systems I work with may help us find research, history, patents or another field where somebody has already encountered something similar.
Or perhaps we’ll all stare at it for a while and remain completely mystified. I don’t regard that as failure. Knowing exactly where our understanding stops is considerably more useful than inventing an explanation because the empty space makes us uncomfortable.
Have Another Look
The next time you use something familiar, give it a few extra seconds before you move on. You don’t have to dismantle the toaster, and I would particularly discourage doing so while it remains connected to the wall. Just look at what happens. What moved? What caused it to move? What had to happen first? What happens next? Why is that piece shaped that way? Who decided it belonged there? What would happen if it weren’t?
You don’t need to answer all those questions. One good question is enough to send you wandering somewhere interesting. And if you find yourself staring at something you’ve seen a thousand times and suddenly wondering How does this damn thing work?, show us the thing and tell us what has you scratching your head. Somebody may know. Somebody may make an unexpected connection. Or we may simply acquire one more good question to worry at.
Any of those outcomes is more interesting than putting the lid back on without ever having looked inside.
