
For most of my life, ideas had a rather convenient habit of arriving without any luggage.
One would simply turn up in my head, rather like an unexpected visitor at the front door, and I would think, Well, hello. Where the hell did you come from?
Then, having asked a perfectly reasonable question, I usually didn’t wait around for the answer.
If the idea looked interesting, I played with it. If it looked useful, I tried to do something with it. If it looked stupid, I occasionally tried to do something with it anyway. That last category has provided a surprising amount of entertainment over the years.
It was a perfectly serviceable arrangement. Idea arrives. Old Git fiddles with it. Something happens. Sometimes something useful. Sometimes something that teaches you why other people had enough sense not to fiddle with it in the first place.
Then I Started Looking Backward
I am eighty-four years old, which gives a man a fairly substantial pile of yesterday to rummage through. I have spent much of those years making things, selling things, promoting things, fixing things, starting businesses and, from time to time, making an impressive mess of one. When I began writing about some of those experiences, I naturally started running into the ideas that had come along with them.
Except now I had something I hadn’t possessed when the ideas originally arrived.
I had the years before them.
Something I saw when I was twelve might still have been lying around somewhere. So might a machine somebody showed me when I was thirty, a problem I couldn’t solve at forty-five, a business that behaved differently from the way I thought businesses were supposed to behave, or a conversation I had last Tuesday.
At the time, none of those things had to look important. They didn’t even have to look related. Most of life does not arrive carrying little labels saying KEEP THIS — YOU WILL NEED IT IN 37 YEARS.
But suppose some of it remains.
Then something new happens. I see something, hear something, run into a problem, make a mistake, have a conversation, or discover once again that the world has declined to behave according to my specifications. And this new thing somehow fits against something that was already there.
That is when I notice the idea.
I Have Become Suspicious of Eureka
We are rather fond of the moment when the lightbulb comes on. Newton gets the apple. Archimedes gets the bathtub. Some poor bastard drops chocolate into peanut butter and civilization advances another inch.
Eureka!
Maybe.
But I’m becoming suspicious of Eureka, because we may be giving the last few seconds of the process credit for everything that happened before them.
The interesting question may not be, What made the lightbulb come on? It may be, What had to be sitting there before there was anything for the switch to connect?
And once I started asking that question about my own ideas, I found myself asking it about damn near everything.
So I Needed a Word
The word I eventually found useful was encounter.
I don’t mean anything mystical by it. An encounter is simply something meeting something else in experience. I see a machine. Somebody tells me something. I meet a person. I run into a problem. I learn how some peculiar little corner of a business works. I make a mistake and discover what was hiding underneath it. I notice something odd and, for no particularly good reason, remember it.
Most encounters may amount to absolutely nothing. They can sit there for years without earning their keep. Some may disappear altogether. I certainly don’t know enough to tell you precisely what the mind keeps, what it loses, or what it can later recover.
But occasionally a new encounter appears to bump into something that was already available, and a relationship becomes visible that wasn’t visible before.
For most of my life I would have described that moment by saying, “I’ve got an idea.”
Now I am wondering whether that sentence starts the story much too late.
The Old Git Model
That wondering eventually grew into what I call the Old Git Model. The name is deliberate. I am the Old Git, and this thing did not begin with me putting on a white coat and announcing a Grand Theory of Human Thought. It began with an elderly fellow rummaging through his own life and asking whether some of his supposedly sudden ideas had left tracks.
Could I take one apart?
Could I identify things that had been encountered earlier and later became useful? Could something learned in one part of life become part of a solution in another part that seemed to have nothing whatsoever to do with it? Could a problem itself cause old material to become useful again?
And perhaps most important: where would the trail disappear?
Because if I am going to claim I know where an idea came from, I had damned well better be able to distinguish what I can actually trace from what merely makes a nice story afterward.
So the Old Git Model is not something I intend to announce as finished and then spend the rest of my time defending. It is something to worry at. We can look at actual experiences, actual ideas, actual mistakes and actual connections and see what survives examination.
Which Is Where You Come In
This website gives us a much larger junk drawer.
I can put my encounters into it. You can put yours into it. We can throw in something happening this morning beside something that happened fifty years ago. A machine can land beside a childhood memory. A business problem can bump into something somebody learned while fishing. One person’s perfectly ordinary experience may contain exactly the piece that causes somebody else to notice a relationship neither of them could have found alone.
Most of it will probably do nothing.
That is all right. A junk drawer in which every object turns out to be indispensable is not a junk drawer. It is an inventory system, and somebody will eventually want us to alphabetize the damned thing.
I’m more interested in the occasional click.
So here’s something worth trying. Think of an idea, solution or odd connection that once seemed to arrive in your head from nowhere. Don’t tell me merely what the idea was. Walk backward. What had you seen, learned, tried, broken, misunderstood, remembered or encountered before it appeared? If you find something interesting back there, bring it over to Your Ideas and tell me what you found.
I don’t know what we’ll discover by doing this. That’s rather the point.
But every once in a while, I suspect somebody is going to stare at two things that had no apparent business knowing one another, hear that little click, and say:
“Well, I’ll be damned. Where the hell did THAT come from?”
