
A couple of nights ago, the Lovely Celeste asked her son Forster whether he would like to stay in an underwater hotel. It was a perfectly reasonable question. Forster is forty, recently moved back to Florida, and has spent enough of his life around Wilmington and Key West to have acquired interests in scuba diving, sailing and the environment. An underwater hotel is exactly the sort of oddball place Celeste might find and think he would enjoy.
So she asked him, and sitting a few feet away, minding his own business, was the Old Git. He heard underwater hotel, and somewhere inside that eighty-four-year accumulation of things that were supposed to have been forgotten, a door opened. Out walked Mrs. Fallaw, bringing with her a redheaded Georgia schoolboy, a research paper and a cake cover that had once been pressed into service in the advancement of science.
There Was This Kid Named Red
It was 1957 or 1958, and Red was in high school when Mrs. Fallaw assigned the class a research paper. She did something teachers occasionally do when they are feeling adventurous: she allowed the students to choose their own subjects. This was a mistake, at least if she expected Red to select something sensible.
Whatever the other students chose has disappeared from memory. The mating habits of the boll weevil may have been represented. Somebody probably did George Washington. There may have been a perfectly respectable paper on the cotton gin. Red decided to investigate underwater cities.
Where that particular question came from is one of the missing pieces. The Old Git would dearly love to know. Had Red read something? Seen something on television? Run across a photograph? Heard somebody talking? Had two completely unrelated scraps of information collided somewhere inside that red head and produced the question? Nearly seventy years later, whatever started it is gone. What survived was the question: Could people actually live underwater?
Once Red had the question, he went after it, which was something Red had a tendency to do when a question interested him more than whatever sensible thing he was supposed to be doing.
Monsanto and Mother’s Cake Cover
Remember, this was the late 1950s. There was no Google. Red couldn’t type underwater city into a little box and spend the next six hours discovering that civilization had already produced seventeen experts, four lunatics, three advertisements and a fellow on YouTube who could explain the whole thing while rebuilding a carburetor. If he wanted information, he had to figure out who might have some and ask for it.
So Red wrote letters to scientists and companies. Monsanto sent technical information and material samples. He tried to understand pressure, materials and some of the other inconveniences involved in putting human beings in a place where the Almighty had neglected to equip them with gills. Then merely writing about the thing ceased to be sufficient, so Red did what Red tended to do under those circumstances and started building.
With help from Mother, he constructed a model of his underwater city, and somewhere in that technological marvel was a cake carrier or cake cover pressed into service for something its manufacturer had almost certainly not anticipated. Nobody should attempt to reconstruct the engineering from the Old Git’s memory and put actual residents inside it, but the model existed. More to the point, Red was the only student in the class who built one.
He had researched the subject, written to people who knew more than he did, acquired technical material from Monsanto, written the paper and built a model. Then Red carried his underwater city to school and turned the whole business over to Mrs. Fallaw, who gave him an F.
Apparently the Ocean Wasn’t Sensible
The problem, as the Old Git remembers it, was not that Mrs. Fallaw had discovered a fatal engineering flaw. She didn’t explain that Red’s materials couldn’t withstand the pressure. She didn’t challenge his research, calculate that the structure would implode, or point out that everybody inside would drown before supper. Her objection was more fundamental than any of that: underwater cities were not a sensible subject.
Mrs. Fallaw offered to let Red do the assignment again if he chose a subject that was sensible. Red was hurt more than angry. There is something peculiar about being young and discovering that an adult you’ve been taught to respect doesn’t merely disagree with your answer. The adult thinks the question that fascinated you wasn’t worth asking in the first place.
Red was, however, educable. Mrs. Fallaw wanted a sensible research paper, and she had now taught him something about sensible research papers. He went to the school library and checked out Rockets and Jets by Willy Ley. Then, according to the Old Git’s recollection, Red substantially copied material from it, manufactured some references and footnotes, dressed the whole business up until it looked properly scholarly, and handed it in.
Mrs. Fallaw gave the second paper an A-minus, along with a note saying it would have been an A-plus if Red had turned it in the first time. There is probably an educational lesson in there somewhere. Red certainly learned one; whether it was the lesson Mrs. Fallaw intended to teach is another matter.
Then Grandmother Found the Navy
About a year later, Red’s grandmother found something in the Sunday newspaper and showed it to him. The United States Navy was doing serious work related to human beings living underwater.
That did not mean Red had invented underwater habitation. It did not prove that his cake-cover metropolis would have survived long enough for anybody to unpack a toothbrush, and there is no evidence that the United States Navy was anxiously awaiting technical guidance from a Georgia schoolboy and his mother. What it did mean was considerably simpler and, to Red, considerably more important: the question wasn’t stupid. People with more education, money, equipment and technical knowledge than Red possessed were asking versions of it too.
Red probably could not have explained then why that mattered so much. The Old Git has had nearly seventy years to worry at it and can do somewhat better. There is an enormous difference between saying, That’s an unlikely idea; let’s see whether it survives contact with reality, and saying, Sensible people don’t investigate things like that. One is skepticism. The other is snootiness.
Red Could Have Used a Skeptic
A good skeptic could have had a wonderful afternoon with Red and his underwater city. How are these people going to breathe? What happens to the structure under pressure? What materials will survive? How do the residents get in and out? What happens when something breaks? Where does the waste go? What happens in an emergency?
Red might not have had a decent answer to half of those questions. Quite possibly some of his answers would have been magnificent sheep dung. But every question would have done something useful because every question would have forced the idea to encounter reality. The city might have changed. Parts might have survived. Other parts might have died immediately and deserved to. Red might have discovered that somebody else had already solved a problem he hadn’t even recognized, or the whole cake-covered enterprise might eventually have collapsed under the weight of its own foolishness.
Any of those outcomes would have taught Red something about underwater cities. Being told that underwater cities were not a sensible subject taught him something entirely different.
Mrs. Fallaw’s Nose
There is no surviving evidence that Mrs. Fallaw possessed an unusual nose, and after nearly seventy years the storyteller is not about to manufacture one for the poor woman. The nose that matters here is the imaginary one human beings sometimes acquire when they are trying very hard to be sophisticated. It can get surprisingly high in the air.
The great advantage of snootiness is efficiency. Once a person has decided an idea is ridiculous, there is no need to examine it. No research is required. No embarrassing questions have to be asked. There is no risk of discovering that the ignorant fellow with the cake cover noticed something everybody else missed. A person can remain perfectly sensible while somebody else wanders off and investigates the damned thing.
The Old Git suspects nearly everybody does some version of that, and he knows perfectly well that he has. Something arrives that doesn’t fit comfortably among the things already accepted as sensible, and before anybody has examined it somebody says, That’s ridiculous. Maybe it is ridiculous. Plenty of things are. But before throwing it away, there is another question worth asking: How the hell did we find out?
That’s the trouble with getting the nose too high. Eventually the damned thing can block the view, and because its owner is looking down, a restricted view can begin to feel remarkably like superior vision.
Then Celeste Asked About the Hotel
Nearly seventy years passed. Red became the Old Git. There were jobs, marriages, children, businesses, inventions, failures, successes, moves, illnesses, deaths and enough assorted living to push Mrs. Fallaw and her F into a very dusty corner of memory.
Then, a couple of nights ago, the Lovely Celeste was talking with Forster. She wasn’t discussing education, creativity, the Navy, Monsanto, Mrs. Fallaw, teenage Red or the proper treatment of unconventional ideas. She had simply found something she thought her son might enjoy, so she asked him whether he would like to stay in an underwater hotel.
And sitting within earshot was the kid with the cake cover, except that the kid was eighty-four years old now and Mrs. Fallaw had been gone from the room for nearly seven decades.
That’s the part that still gets the Old Git. The world doesn’t always announce when something ridiculous becomes ordinary. There may be no trumpet, no ceremony and certainly no delegation arriving to apologize for having thought it foolish. Sometimes nearly seventy years pass, and then your wife casually mentions the damned thing to your son as a possible place to spend the night.
Have You Ever Been Handed an F?
Not necessarily an actual grade, although that certainly counts. Somewhere along the way, somebody may have told you that a question wasn’t worth asking. It might have been a teacher, boss, parent, customer, spouse, expert or friend. Nobody else may have been required at all; plenty of peculiar thoughts have probably been strangled by their owners after one quick glance suggested that respectable people wouldn’t entertain such nonsense.
The Old Git isn’t looking for stories in which everybody turns out to have been a misunderstood genius. Most people aren’t, and most ridiculous ideas are probably ridiculous for excellent reasons. What interests him is the question that got dismissed before anybody bothered to discover whether it deserved dismissal.
If you’ve carried one of those around, bring your own cake-cover idea over to Your Ideas and tell the Old Git what happened to it. Tell him what fascinated you, who thought it was foolish and, especially, whether you ever found out what happened to the question afterward.
Skepticism is welcome in Gitland. A good skeptic can poke holes in an idea, expose its nonsense, force it to deal with reality and occasionally kill the poor thing before somebody spends the mortgage money on it. Snootiness isn’t nearly as useful. It merely decides there is nothing worth looking at and moves along.
Every once in a while, it might be wise to lower the nose far enough to see the damned thing before passing judgment. Most of the time there may be nothing there. But once in a great while, seventy years later, somebody may be booking a room in it.
